Showing posts with label connemara pony. Show all posts
Showing posts with label connemara pony. Show all posts

Saturday, November 5, 2016

United Kingdom: Stephanie Noble turned her living room into a horse stable, police say

UNITED KINGDOM -- There was no way a horse being stabled in the front room of a residential house “would come out alive” if it crashed through the floor, a court has been told.

 

Western Isles Council seized Stephanie Ann Noble’s adult Connemara pony, called Grey Lady Too, in February 2014, claiming its living conditions for the previous two years in the front room of the ex-council house at Broadbay View, Back, in Lewis, were too cramped and broke guidelines.

Though Ms Noble is still the official owner, the local authority is forced to pay thousands of pounds in looking after it, about four times its value.

The council has gone to court to try and obtain legal ownership and sell the horse.

 

A legal blunder resulted in the council’s earlier bid to abolish Ms Noble’s rights to the animal being thrown out by a sheriff.

Stornoway Sheriff Court previously heard Ms Noble cleared the living room of all furniture to rig up a makeshift stable after grazing arrangements suddenly stopped during Christmas 2011.

Yesterday advocate Stewart Buchanan, representing Ms Noble, said the council took no action for a long period despite its claims Grey Lady Too would suffer if did not move out of the house.

 

He maintained there were no realistic risks after it moved in, otherwise the council “would have taken steps to protect the animal.”

Giving evidence, council animal health inspector Kenny Macleod said he was looking at the long term issues including a “massive risk” of the wooden floorboard rotting from “gallons of urine going down on it.”

“If the horse went through the floor it would not come out of that house alive,” he emphasized.

There was also the hazard of it jumping through the window.


Mr Macleod said: “The whole case is to do with the long term suffering of the horse."

The case before Sheriff David Sutherland was adjourned to a later date.

(Press and Journal UK - Nov 4, 2016)

Earlier:

Thursday, May 21, 2015

United Kingdom: Horse evicted from Stephanie Noble's Western Isles house could return home after court gaffe

UNITED KINGDOM -- A horse evicted by Western Isles Council from the front room she was living in could return home after her owner won a legal battle.

Western Isles Council evicted Stephanie Ann Noble’s prize pony from her Isle of Lewis home, however, three words missing from a court document meant Western Isles Council’s case has now been thrown out.


Despite the ruling, the council still adamantly refuses to hand the animal back.

Western Isles Council effectively took Ms Noble’s adult Connemara pony into care, claiming its living conditions for the previous two years in the front room of the ex-council house were too cramped.

Ms Noble is still the legal owner but since last February, the council has racked up a huge bill in looking after it at stables on a different island.

The local authority went to court seeking ownership of the horse, called Grey Lady Too, which would abolish all Ms Noble’s rights to the animal.


But a council blunder meant Ms Noble’s name was missing from vital legal documents, creating a phantom court case.

It meant the council failed to specify who it was taking the legal action against.

Sheriff David Hall threw out the council’s case and ordered them to pay Ms Noble’s legal fees.

However, the council is digging its hooves in and refuses to return the horse, saying it will consider either appealing the sheriff’s decision or starting the legal action all over again.


Ms Noble clutched a copy of Horse and Hound magazine as she observed the legal debate at Stornoway Sheriff Court this afternoon.

Advocate Stewart Buchanan – representing Ms Noble – repeatedly insisted that the council’s case was not competent.

Mr Stewart stressed the omission of Ms Noble’s details from the court paperwork was a “radical defect.”


He highlighted: “Without a defender there just hasn’t ever been a (legal) application before the court.”

Naming the person the case is against is “fundamental to the litigation” he added.

He said: “Ms Noble is prejudice by the first document that started all this off. It is simply not a document recognised by the court.”


In court, Western Isles Council accepted the “unfortunate” omission, acknowledging it would have been “absolutely better” if Ms Noble’s name had been included.

But the error was “not fatal“ and should not stop the case progressing, said the council.

The council’s agent suggested it was simply a “technicality  and urged the sheriff to correct the mistake there and then, saying he had discretion to do so.


The council lawyer pointed out that the case was costing great expense to the public purse.

She said Ms Noble had not only answered the citation but had been legally represented during the last year.

Sheriff David Hall concluded “in favor of the defender” and dismissed the council’s action.

Ms Noble beamed with joy as the sheriff delivered his decision but declined to comment “at this stage.”


However, the council insists it has no intention of returning the horse, saying it may appeal or resubmit proper legal documents.

A council spokesman said: “Grey Lady Too was removed for welfare reasons and will remain in the care of the council. The decision today will delay the ultimate determination of what happens to the pony.

“Today’s hearing related to procedural matters and the council will consider the findings. The council continues to act in the interests of the welfare of Grey Lady Too.”

Ms Noble purchased the animal in Ireland for nearly £1,900 in 2011 but faced a raft of problems in securing grazings nearby.


The former riding school operator, originally from Londonderry, took the animal indoors that same year, claiming it had no winter shelter.

But the supposedly temporary arrangement continued for well over two years.

The 68-year-old stayed in a bedroom upstairs while the rest of her home was given to the horse.

(Press and Journal - May 20, 2015)

Earlier:

Friday, January 13, 2012

United Kingdom: Stephanie Noble causes outrage on small island by keeping pony in living room of house

UNITED KINGDOM -- It is an average, neat semi-detached house on a remote Scottish island, owned by a divorcee animal lover in her sixties.

But Stephanie Noble has horrified neighbors in Back, Lewis, after moving in her pet pony as a lodger.

 

The three-year-old dapple grey, named Grey Lady Too, has taken up residence in Miss Noble’s living room after a dispute over grazing left the filly without a field.

Her owner has put in a hay bed and turned her chairs into feeding troughs to accommodate the animal, which she now refuses to move.

Miss Noble is now the subject of numerous complaints and visits from her local council and the Scottish SPCA, but because it is her own home officials said last night there is nothing they can do.


Miss Noble said: ‘This is my own property - if I want to even keep an elephant in the house I can. I have had nothing but stick from people because it is unconventional.

‘It is not normal to keep birds in a cage, because they should be flying about, but people don’t complain about that. Grey Lady Too is very happy.

‘She goes out to the lawn - though she has eaten a couple of the neighbor’s plants - and comes back in the house herself. The situation is not ideal, but it is safe and secure for her.’


Neighbors beside the semi-detached home in Broadbay View say they often see the horse staring out of the ground-floor living room as they pass.

Grey Lady Too – named after Miss Noble’s first pony, Grey Lady – has two chairs full of straw to feed from and a bucket of drinking water regularly refilled from the kitchen next door.

In the living room, close to a desk and chair is the pony’s bed of hay, on top of 60 litres (more than 200 pounds) of cat litter and four heavy-duty rugs for the filly’s droppings and urine.

The pony was kept on land a few miles from the house after Miss Noble bought her in September, but moved because the grazing was ‘unsuitable’.

Taken to land in the nearby village of Gress, the filly was left on Miss Noble’s property on Christmas Eve, she says, after a dispute over payment.

She spent a night in the cells after putting the pony in a nearby shed, which she says she believed was in common ownership.


The ensuing argument with the property owner saw her reported to the procurator fiscal for an alleged breach of the peace and vandalism.

After that, she took the pony into her house.

The owner said: ‘I will sell myself before I sell that pony. I don’t think any horse or pony should be out in this climate in winter. All I’m doing is fighting for my rights against people, who because it’s unconventional, think it’s wrong.

'I would love somebody to come up with suitable nearby grazing.’

In the meantime, the £1,850 pony, which is not yet broken-in, remains in the living room.


Miss Noble, a qualified British Horse Society instructor who lived in America until 1994, hopes to eventually use the filly for breeding. Her neighbors, however, are less than happy with the bizarre set-up.

One said: ‘Who in their right mind would ever want their next-door neighbor to be a horse? The problem is not unsympathetic neighbors. She has been a pain in the neck from the minute she got here.’


Another described the divorcee as a ‘fruitcake’, while a neighbor added: ‘People are concerned about the horse and her.

‘The horse walks in and out of her house like it is its stable. It is put out into the garden, which is not the kind of space I can imagine a horse needs.’

The Scottish SPCA has offered to take the pony in but been refused. Inspector Andy Brown said yesterday: ‘We are concerned about the welfare of the pony. But it does appear to be in good condition and well cared for.

‘We are hoping to discuss the matter with Ms Noble. It is an unusual case.’


Miss Noble was not answering her door last night, but a spokesman from Western Isles Council said she was free to do as she pleased in her own property as long as public safety or hygiene were not affected.

He said: ‘We don’t encourage people to keep horses in their homes.’

(Daily Mail - Jan 12, 2012)