Saturday, August 13, 2011

Gig Harbor dog-mauling victim awarded $2.2 million

WASHINGTON -- A Pierce County jury Friday awarded $2.2 million in damages to a Gig Harbor woman who was mauled by two pit bulls that entered her home through an open sliding-glass door four years ago.

Sue Gorman at a press conference after the attack

The bulk of the judgment will be split between the owners of one of the pit bulls and Pierce County.

The jury found Shellie Wilson and her son, Zachary Martin, 52 percent liable for the injuries and property damage suffered by Sue Gorman during the mauling.

Martin owned one of the animals, named Betty, that attacked Gorman, and he and his mother were looking after the other, named Tank. They’ll have to pay about $1.1 million to Gorman.

Gorman with her Sheltie Misty

Jurors assigned 42 percent of the blame to Pierce County, which will have to pay about $924,000.

Gorman’s attorneys – Michael McKasy and Shelly Speir – argued during trial that county animal control was negligent for not taking action against Wilson and Martin despite having received numerous complaints about their dogs running loose and terrorizing people.

Shellie and her son will have to cough up more
than ONE MILLION DOLLARS for the death
and destruction caused by the wigglebutt pit bulls

Gorman filed two complaints about her neighbors’ dogs in the months before the attack on Aug. 21, 2007.

The jury assigned 5 percent of the blame for the attack to Jacqueline Evans-Hubbard, who left Tank in the care of Wilson and Martin when she went out of town.

Jurors said Gorman was 1 percent to blame.


The sliding glass door left ajar and the
bloody mayhem caused by the pit bulls

McKasy, who talked to jurors after the verdict, said they expressed particular concern that county animal control did not do more to address neighbors’ complaints about Martin and Wilson’s animals.

“They had 14 complaints,” he said. “The dog (Betty) could have and should have been confiscated.”

Efforts to reach county officials for comment were unsuccessful Friday, as were attempts to reach Wilson and Martin and their attorney.

The county’s attorney, Ron Williams, argued during trial that Wilson and Martin were to blame for Gorman’s injuries for not keeping Betty and Tank under control and confined to their property.

Gorman was mauled after awakening to find Betty and Tank in her bedroom attacking her service dog [a Sheltie named Misty] and a neighbor’s Jack Russell terrier.

She had left her sliding-glass door opened so Misty and Romeo could come and go from her house.

She was mauled when she tried to pull the pit bulls off the other dogs. Romeo, the Jack Russell terrier, died in the attack, and the two pit bulls later were put down after their owners surrendered them to animal control. Misty survived.

Gorman suffered bites to her arms, face, neck, chest and nose and was hospitalized briefly after the attack.

Faces of death: "blame the deed,
not the breed!" say the nutters

It’s unclear how the pit bulls escaped Wilson’s and Martin’s house that morning.


(News Tribune - August 13, 2011)