Tuesday, December 24, 2013

Judge Dave Tobben orders rabbits and other animals to be returned to abuser Velma Muessemeyer

MISSOURI -- A Franklin County judge has ordered a large number of animals seized in an investigation last month returned to a St. Clair area woman.

Associate Circuit Judge Dave Tobben heard testimony and arguments Wednesday from both sides in the case of Velma Muessemeyer, 75, known locally as the “Rabbit Lady,”

After taking the case under advisement, Tobben issued his judgment Thursday.

Dave Tobben says this isn't cruel confinement

Tobben, in his ruling, noted that while the state’s experts stated that “generally there was indication of neglect,” and that some of the animals were underweight and/or ill, “there was no evidence that the vast majority of the animals were in danger.”

On Tuesday, Nov. 12, members of the Missouri Humane Society’s Animal Cruelty Task Force and Franklin County deputies removed 253 animals from Muessemeyer’s property off of Parkway Drive just east of the St. Clair city limits.

An investigation led to a warrant ordering removal of the animals, including 192 domestic rabbits, 25 goats, 10 cats, 21 chickens, four dogs and a duck.

Prosecuting Attorney Bob Parks said the humane society reported that a number of the animals were in such poor health that they had to be euthanized.

Parks said he was “extremely disappointed” with Tobben’s ruling but that will not stop his office from proceeding with criminal charges against Muessemeyer.

Free to continue to abuse animals, thanks to Dave Tobben

Muessemeyer is charged with 21 separate misdemeanor counts of animal abuse based on reports filed by the humane society.

Parks said he issued charges in the “worst cases” of animal abuse documented by humane society workers. Criminal summonses were issued in the case.

The prosecutor said the misdemeanor charges are based on individual cases of alleged animal neglect and are separate from the hearing to decide custody of the animals.

The penalties for misdemeanor animal abuse range from one day to a year in the county jail, and up to a $1,000 fine on each count.

The prosecutor said his office will ask the court to order restitution payments to the humane society for removal, treatment and care of the animals.

Parks said as of Friday, that bill had increased to more than $80,000.

Muessemeyer told The Missourian that she raises rabbits for sale and she denied that the animals were housed in unsanitary conditions.

 Authorities, however, alleged that the rabbits were housed in raised wire-bottom cages with feces piled in the cages as well as underneath them. Many of the cages were encrusted with dirt and hair and had little to no shelter from the weather.

Most of the cages held multiple rabbits with some housing as many as 10. Water for many of the animals was frozen, dirty and contaminated with feces, authorities alleged.

(Missourian - Dec 20, 2013)

"Nearly 200 rabbits, dogs, cats and other animals rescued in Franklin County"
Nov 12, 2013 -- Velma Muessemeyer said she has been raising rabbits for more than sixty years and there was nothing wrong with her methods.  But authorities described the conditions for nearly two hundred rabbits and 25 pigmy goats as ‘deplorable.’

As many as thirteen domestic rabbits were crowded into one wire cage. 

Muessemeyer said she was getting ready to butcher some of them.  ‘This was part of my living cause I don`t  get a lot of Social Security so this was to help me out,’ she explained.

The woman admitted, ‘rabbits are messy, yes they are messy and they are a lot of work, but I go through fifty pounds of feed a day.’


  1. What a horrible mess. You just have to look at it all to see it's substandard care. Judge made a very poor ruling and is encouraging animal abuse. I hope there are followup actions to get this decision reversed!

  2. maybe the judge should help to clean it all up and get it up to decent standards! he just gave this woman a license to abuse and neglect innocent animals! this is disgusting and should be appealed and go to a higher court! Too many people are trying to make do with their social security only to live on! they sure don't abuse and neglect animals... if she can afford 50 lbs of feed a day then I'd say she's got mighty profitable business going there... but is the money she's actually making being reported as income? Yes, I know how hard it is to live on SS because I too depend on only that for my income. I feed feral cats in my neighborhood and donate what I can when I can and have a rescue dog as well... I sure don't have a bunch of dilapidated cages full of innocent animals that are in danger of getting ill or worse!