Tuesday, November 30, 2010

Louisiana: Despite begging for leniency, man receives 5 years in prison for stealing calf, beating it to death

LOUISIANA -- Moments after telling a St. Tammany Parish courtroom that time in prison "would ruin my life completely," 22-year-old David J. LeBlanc Jr. listened Monday as a judge sentenced him to five years in prison for stealing a newborn calf and beating it to death with a shovel last winter.

LeBlanc, one of several men arrested in the case, landed the harshest sentence because he alone caused the defenseless animal "a painful death," state Judge Martin Coady explained.

David J. LeBlanc Jr.

On Dec. 19, 2009, LeBlanc's night of drinking at a Saints party at an apartment complex on Louisiana 1078 near Folsom was spoiled by the team's loss to the Dallas Cowboys.
He; Dwayne J. Jenkins, 36; and Carnie B. Smith, 29, vented their frustration by stealing a 3-day-old calf from nearby Red Bluff Farm, where school children often visit on field trips to learn about farming.

  


They dragged the animal back to the apartment complex's parking lot. There, as Jenkins and Smith watched, LeBlanc pummeled the calf with a shovel until it died.

The farm called the St. Tammany Parish Sheriff's Office out the next morning to investigate the calf's disappearance. Deputies found evidence that the calf had been dragged under the farm's fence, and footprints led them to the apartment complex.

Jenkins, Smith, LeBlanc and a fourth man, Christopher R. Murphy, 27, of Franklinton, were all eventually arrested. St. Tammany Parish Assistant District Attorney Harold Bartholomew secured guilty pleas from all of them.

Jenkins and Smith in October each received two years of probation and were ordered to pay back their share of the price of the calf. Murphy received two years' probation, too -- though he did not participate in killing or stealing the animal, he did remove the calf's carcass, drive it into the wilderness and dump it, authorities said.

As the time neared Monday for LeBlanc to learn his fate, he told Judge Coady that he deserved the same sentence if not a lighter one than his fellow defendants got.

Christopher Murphy

"I was the only one who came forth and told the truth" during interviews with investigators, LeBlanc said. "The others lied the whole time."

LeBlanc then begged the judge to have sympathy for his relatives and his unborn child.

"I have a kid on the way," he said. "I could not do (time in prison). My family could not."

Coady replied that, though the pre-sentencing investigation he ordered confirmed that LeBlanc cooperated with deputies, it was not enough to save him out from being imprisoned.

Carnie B. Smith

Aside from the five-year sentence, Coady ordered LeBlanc to pay restitution to the calf's owner; to undergo psychiatric evaluation; and to keep away from all animals. The judge also recommended that LeBlanc apply for a boot camp program through which he could shave off part of his sentence, but acceptance into the program is not automatic, said Rick Wood, a District Attorney's spokesman.

LeBlanc, who wore a black hooded sweatshirt and denim jeans, was handcuffed by a deputy at the conclusion of the hearing. He slumped into a nearby bench, slowly shook his head and buried his face into his hands.

Two women and one man who accompanied him stood up to leave the room with dazed expressions on their faces.

"Oh my God," one woman said, her voice quivering. "Wow," said the other.


(The Times-Picayune - Nov 29, 2010)

Friday, November 26, 2010

Bulldogs attack 10-year-old girl in Massachusetts

MASSACHUSETTS -- A 10-year-old girl is recovering at home in the western Massachusetts town of Granby after two bulldogs attacked her in the neighbor’s yard.

The Daily Hampshire Gazette reports that the girl was bitten several times on Saturday. She was treated at Baystate Medical Center in Springfield and released. Authorities withheld her identity .

The owner of the American bulldogs plans to euthanize them after a required 10-day period.

In Maine, Karen Stewart, 41, of Prentiss Township was mauled on Nov. 12 by an American bulldog mix in LaGrange. She was removed earlier this week from a drug-induced coma at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston, and has undergone surgeries to clean out infected tissue. She may lose one of her arms because of the damage to it.

Stewart had been visiting her friend Vaughn Adams of LaGrange when she was severely mauled by an unleashed American bulldog mix owned by Adam Bemis, 28, one of Adams’ neighbors. Stewart was bitten more than 20 times on her head, face, arms and legs.

The dog was euthanized shortly after to be tested for rabies. Bemis has been charged with keeping a dangerous dog and may face additional charges, police have said.

As with the dog in Maine, Granby Dog Officer Gordon Landry says there had been no previous reports of problems with the dogs.

The American bulldog is a stocky, strong-looking animal with powerful jaws. The canine is sometimes known not to tolerate not-so-familiar friends approaching its territory when the owner is not around.

(Bangor Daily News - Nov 25, 2010)

Sunday, November 21, 2010

Court orders dog that killed therapy dog to be euthanized

MAINE -- A Lewiston judge ordered a Livermore Falls man Tuesday to have his dog euthanized by Nov. 24, for attacking and killing a therapy dog in July on lower Park Street.

Martin Vining
Jack, a Jack Russell terrier, was being walked on a leash by its owner's children when the Bull Mastiff - Mastiff - Rottweiler mix named Hooch attacked him near the larger dog's residence at 46 Park St.

Martin Vining, 41, pleaded guilty in 8th District Court to civil violations of having a dog-at-large, having an unlicensed dog and being owner/keeper of a dangerous dog, Animal Control Officer Wayne Atwood said Friday.

Vining was ordered to pay $450 in restitution, a $100 fine for the unlicensed dog violation and a $250 fine for the dangerous dog violation, Livermore Falls police administrative assistant Amanda Leclerc said.

The judge ordered that the dog be euthanized by Wednesday, Nov. 24, and ordered a copy of the euthanization papers to be sent to the Androscoggin County District Attorney's Office by Tuesday, Nov. 30, Atwood said.

Vining was not available for comment Friday.

“On Nov. 16 justice was carried out for the death of our beloved Jack,” owner Bethany Miller of Livermore Falls said Friday. “It is my hope that our town will be a safer place to be because of Jack's story. We would like to thank the Livermore Falls police, Mr. Atwood and the District Attorney's Office for the respectful way they handled our case. I feel bad for Mr. Vining and Hooch but the public's safety had to come first.”

Jack was Miller's therapy dog. She said previously that she and her family were devastated when Jack, 4, was killed. She had planned at the time to get counseling for her children, ages 14 to 19, who had to watch the attack. Attempts made to separate the dogs were unsuccessful and the smaller dog died during the [attack].

Miller's biggest concern then was that she didn't want to see anybody else get hurt by the larger dog.
Hooch had also attacked a mailman in 2007. Vining was charged then with owning a dangerous dog.


Miller’s children and Jack were returning from a walk at the Livermore Falls Recreation Field and were about a half-mile from home when Hooch came around a corner near Vining's home.

Her son, Kyle Wilson, 19, said previously that Hooch gave his younger brother, Jordan Gill, 14, a look and Jack took a step toward the larger dog, and Hooch attacked it.

Vining said previously that he was outside burying another of his dogs that had been hit by a vehicle and had to be put down. Hooch was not on a leash at the time but was initially with Vining and a friend in the yard.

"Nothing was done on purpose," Vining said at the time. He didn't know why Hooch went after the smaller dog, he said, but he knew Hooch, who was 9 [years old] at the time, didn't get along with Jack.

(Sun Journal - Nov 20, 2010)
Earlier:

Saturday, November 20, 2010

Two separate dog attacks reported to Saline police

MICHIGAN -- Saline police say they're investigating two recent serious dog attacks in which one dog attacked another while owners were walking them in the city.

The most recent incident was reported last Thursday after a woman reported her dog was attacked and bitten by a stranger's dog in Mill Pond Park.

The woman said she was walking her basset hound in the park at 565 Bennett St. at about 6:30 p.m. when it approached another dog walking with a younger couple, according to reports. The other dog, which resembled a [Doberman Pinscher], attacked the woman’s dog as soon as the owners let her off her leash. It took several minutes to separate the animals, and the attacking dog’s owners left the park quickly.

The basset hound’s owner told police the dog was injured, but she felt the wounds weren't serious enough to require medical attention. She told officers she didn't wish to press charges, but wanted the owners warned not to unleash their pets in the park.

She didn't get the people’s names, but was able to describe the license plate of the vehicle they were in for officers. A notice was mailed to the vehicle’s owner regarding the city’s animal ordinance, and the case remains open pending contact with those individuals, reports said.

Officers are still trying to identify the owners of a dog that attacked a Saline woman’s dog as they were walking along the sidewalk in the 900 block of Colony Drive on Sept. 29, reports said.

The woman said she was taking her daily walk at about 4:45 p.m. when she saw a young girl, roughly 12 years old, walking toward them holding two dogs on leashes. The woman said she yielded the sidewalk to the larger dogs, which were able to pull the girl toward her and her golden retriever.

One of the dogs bit the woman’s dog, causing a wound that would later required sutures. They separated the dogs, and the girl left after giving the woman her cell phone number. The breed of the attacking dog wasn't known, but it was described as weighing roughly 75 pounds.

[Later news stories say it was a pit bull]

The woman said her dog was expected to recover, but she wanted the other dog’s owner to reimburse her for more than $400 in veterinarian bills, reports said.

The woman told police she called the girl’s cell phone and spoke with a woman who identified herself as the girl's mother. Upon explaining the situation, the woman said the girl’s mother abruptly hung up on her and has not returned multiple voicemail messages left since then.

Authorities were able to determine the girl’s cell phone service provider and faxed a subpoena to the company requesting the owner’s contact information, reports said. They are still awaiting results of the subpoena request.

Anyone with information is asked to call the department at 734-429-7911.

(AnnArbor.com - Oct 19, 2010)

Friday, November 19, 2010

Minnesota: James Shuper, 74, and Carol Shuper, 72, to be charged with animal cruelty

MINNESOTA -- A complaint has been filed, and a summons has been issued by St. Louis County Court for the couple found in possession of 30 dogs and one cat at their urban Hibbing home in June.

James A. Shuper, 74, and Carol E. Shuper, 72, are each expected to be charged with 25 counts of animal mistreatment and 30 counts of animal neglect, stemming from the discovery and removal of the animals from their home at 1525 16th Ave. E. on June 8.rec

The mistreatment charge alleges that the Shupers deprived the animals of necessary food, water and shelter, whereas the neglect charge maintains that they failed to provide proper sanitation for the animals in their control.

All of the counts are misdemeanors and carry a maximum sentence of 90 days jail.


Following up on an anonymous tip, Hibbing Animal Control Officer Alyssa Garcia recruited the help of the Hibbing Police Department. She and an officer then visited the residence, which the anonymous caller estimated had 20 dogs inside.

City ordinance states that urban residents may not have more than four dogs or cats at a time.

On scene, Garcia and the officer noticed many bags of dog food in old vehicles located on the lot and noted a strong odor of urine and feces around the outside of the home, according to the complaint.

On a second knocking at the front door, James Shuper answered and told the officer he had four dogs of his own in the home.

When asked if there were any more dogs in the residence, Shuper hesitated but stated “maybe 20.”

According to the complaint, Shuper stated that he had so many “because other people had given him the dogs,” adding that “he believed they would die if they were not cared for.” He did not provide the names of any individuals who gave him the dogs.

Upon entering the house, the officer and Garcia noted the odor was stronger and started to gag for fresh air. They went outside the residence and called for another officer as well as Hibbing Animal Shelter employees to respond with pet crates.

When they re-entered the home, the officer observed 20 dogs in the living room area. They were described as undernourished with their ribs protruding, weeping eyes due to infections and having overgrown nails, according to the complaint.

Blood was also spotted on the wood floors in several area of the house because many of the dogs had bloody feet.

Carol Shuper was home at the time and yelled at the officer and Garcia to “leave (her) dogs alone.”

While removing the animals, an officer was bit in the hand and transported by ambulance to the University Medical Center-Mesabi for treatment. Two animal shelter workers were also bit.

Urine stains on the walls and balls of fur were found throughout the house. In the basement, there was about 1 to 2 inches of feces.

Several dogs were found scared and hiding under the stairs in the basement. Officers needed flashlights and choke collars to get them out. These dogs were described by Garcia as “extremely wild and untamed,” states the complaint.

At the shelter, veterinarian K. Michele Dougan determined that 25 of the 30 dogs seized were emaciated. She further found that all of the dogs had eye irritation and eye drainage due to the ammonia fumes from the accumulation of urine and feces in the home.


All but four of the dogs were described by Dougan as “absolutely filthy,” and several of the dogs were covered in fecal matter. She also determined that the dogs didn’t have enough food, didn’t receive proper hygiene and that their area of confinement was too small and lacked ventilation, according to the complaint.

“This is something that you see on ‘Animals Cops’ or something like that. It’s not something you expect to have here,” Garcia said. “I know it’s out there. It’s just hard to believe until you live it.”

The dogs were nursed back to health by shelter staff and went up for adoption about one month after the date of the rescue. The dogs, which were all Papillion and Chihuahua crosses, had been given shots and were spayed/neutered.

Only five of the rescued dogs are still waiting to be adopted.

(Fergus Falls Journal - November 18, 2010)

Ida Grove woman dead after attacked by own dog

IOWA -- An Ida Grove, Iowa woman is dead after being bitten multiple times by her own dog. Her body was discovered in her home on Monday.

However, officials believe Lou Bird, 79, was attacked by her dog a few days earlier on November 8.

Bird lived at 502 Moorehead Street with only her German Shepherd guard dog.


The Ida County Sheriff believes Bird was in the kitchen with the dog, when she was bit several times. She sustained severe wounds on her hands and the back of her legs.

According to investigators she then went to the bathroom, closed the door, and tried to clean herself up, and got into the bathtub. That's where sheriff's deputies found her on Monday.

"We were notified at about 10 o'clock by a family member they were concerned they weren't able to reach her in a few days so one of our officers went to do a welfare check, went into the residence and subsequently found her deceased in the bath tub," said Ida County Sheriff Wade Harriman.

According to Harriman, Bird was on a blood thinner and believed it contributed to her death, saying it would have been difficult for her blood to clot after being bitten.

Authorities also say Bird had a history of struggling to control her dog. Neighbors say the dog was a constant concern for them.

"I thought he might jump over the fence some day and get my kids so I wasn't happy about the dog," said neighbor Luann Nakazawa.

By family request and city ordinance, the dog has been put down.

Officials are calling the death an accident. Bird is survived by her son.

(KTIV - November 18, 2010)

Humane officer, rescue group took 3 abused horses from a Portage County farm littered with cow bones

OHIO -- Three horses were confiscated last week from a Portage County farm. Animal neglect or cruelty charges will be filed this week, officials said.

The Portage Animal Protective League's humane officer, Jeff Hartung, and a sheriff's deputy went to the farm Sept. 5 after a woman reported finding a horse loose in the street.

Investigators found underweight horses and one that had long, deformed hooves. They also found the skeletons of about 30 cows scattered outside the barn.


"The owner claimed that his herd of cows got pneumonia and died about three years ago," said Annette Fisher, director of Happy Trails Farm Animal Sanctuary in Ravenna.

Fisher's volunteers will care for the horses while the case moves through Portage County Municipal Court.

"The condition of the one horse's hooves was catastrophic, and it was evident that the horse did not have its hooves trimmed for at least a year and a half, and it had extreme difficulty walking," Fisher said. "None of the animals had water."

The name of the farmer will be released once charges are filed.

(Plain Dealer - November 18, 2010)

Nov 19, 2010 Update: Deerfield Township resident Brad Montgomery, 50, was charged Tuesday with three counts of cruelty to animals.

Three horses suffering from malnutrition and overgrown hooves were confiscated from his property on Ohio 14 and are recovering at Happy Trails Farm Animal Sanctuary in Ravenna.

The Portage County Animal Protective League's humane officer, Jeff Hartung, and a sheriff's deputy went to the farm Sept. 5 after a woman reported finding a horse loose in the street. They found the horses living among the skeletons of about 30 cows.

"The owner claimed that his cows got pneumonia and died about three years ago," Happy Trails founder Annette Fisher said. "The condition of the one horse's hooves was catastrophic, making it extremely difficult to walk. None of the animals had water." The case will move through Portage County Municipal Court.

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

Dog attack victim was “ripped apart”

MAINE -- A woman who was “ripped apart” by a mixed breed dog Friday in LaGrange was airlifted over the weekend from Eastern Maine Medical Center in Bangor to the Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston.

Karen Stewart, 41, of the Mattawamkeag area has been placed in a drug-induced coma for her pain, according to her friend Vaughn Adams of LaGrange.

Vaughn Adams describes Ms. Stewart's injuries

“It’s still touch and go,” Adams said late Monday afternoon of Stewart’s condition.

Hospital officials would not release any information about Stewart on Monday.

Adams said Stewart, who is disabled, had been staying a few days at his Forest Street home when she decided to go for a walk alone Friday night and was attacked by a neighbor’s dog. Somehow she managed to drag herself back to his home, he said.

“She was head to toe in blood and mud,” Adams recalled Monday. The dog “took her elbow out, chewed her whole forearm so there was just skin and bone left, her right arm had about a 3-inch-deep by a 4-inch-wide bite taken out, and she had some bites on her head, neck and face.” He said the dog ripped off most of her blouse and tore her pants.


Adams said Stewart, who weighs about 235 pounds and is about 5 feet 6 inches tall, was “ripped apart” and had more than 20 bites on her body.

“When I went to wrap something around her arm, I noticed her elbow was missing,” Adams said. He said he hollered to some other guests in his home to call 911 while he grabbed jackets, a curtain and whatever else he could find to wrap around Stewart’s arms to stop the bleeding. The worst bites were on her arms, so it appeared she was trying to protect herself from the animal, he said.

After the attack, Stewart was taken by ambulance to Penquis Valley High School in Milo, where she was taken by LifeFlight helicopter to EMMC.

The Maine State Police, who earlier reported that the dog was an American bulldog, have charged the animal’s owner, Adam Bemis, 28, with keeping a dangerous dog. Additional charges are possible as the investigation continues, state police Lt. Wesley Hussey said Monday. He said the case will be presented to Penobscot County District Attorney R. Christopher Almy for his review.

Hussey said the dog was taken to the Bangor Humane Society, where it has been placed under quarantine for at least 10 days. He said his department has been in contact with the state Department of Agriculture’s Animal Welfare Program regarding the dog’s future.

The dog which tore apart Ms. Stewart's arms

Adams said he has known Bemis for 17 years. Bemis has had the large, solidly built dog for several months and has always let it roam unrestricted, he stated.

Adams noted that Stewart was aware his neighbor had dogs but was unaware they were not restrained.

Bemis, who has an unlisted telephone number, could not be reached by telephone Monday for comment.

LaGrange Town Clerk Ella Lyford said Bemis had not licensed the dog with her office.

(Bangor Daily News - Nov 15, 2010)

Earlier:

Saturday, November 13, 2010

Woman’s injury major in LaGrange dog bite

MAINE -- A woman who was attacked by a neighbor’s American Bulldog Friday evening was in critical condition Saturday.

Karen Stewart, 41, was mauled and dragged by the bulldog around 6 p.m. Friday while she was out for a walk on a dirt road that serves as a driveway connecting three different residences off Forest Street.


Police characterized her injuries as “life-threatening.”

“She was walking down a dirt driveway and it was dark,” Maine State Trooper Barry Meserve said Sunday. “The neighbor’s dog apparently attacked her for some reason, but we don’t know why because we haven’t talked to her. She’s still unable to talk.

“The dog is a little bit bigger than a standard bulldog and is maybe 70 to 80 pounds,” Meserve added. “I believe the dog is a purebred, but I haven’t seen any papers. The dog was not chained.”

The dog’s owner is 28-year-old Alden Bemis of 18 Forest St.

“The dog’s owner has been charged with keeping a dangerous dog, but it’s safe to say there may be more charges once the investigation is finished,” said Meserve. “In a normal dog bite case, we wouldn’t be involved, but this is a life-threatening case. We get the occasional dog bite call, but nothing like this.”

The dog that attacked Ms. Stewart

Meserve said there was evidence that the dog dragged Stewart during the attack.

“She was dragged some ways, and evidently was able to crawl back to the residence she was staying at and yell for help and they tried to give her as much aid as they could,” Meserve said.

Stewart was taken by ambulance to Penquis Valley High School in Milo, where she was picked up by a LifeFlight helicopter and flown to Eastern Maine Medical Center in Bangor.

“I guess you can assume the dog knocked her down somehow, but we don’t know what provoked the attack,” Meserve said. “She’s still unable to talk. When I last spoke to her boyfriend Saturday morning, it was pretty much touch-and-go.”

Karen Stewart, in an older photo
provided by her family

Stewart had been staying with friends nearby, and her permanent residence was not known, according to Meserve.

A nursing supervisor from Eastern Maine Medical Center had no information available on Stewart or her condition Sunday afternoon.

The dog has been quarantined at a public facility while police investigate the attack and the dog’s history and status.

(Bangor Daily News -  Nov 12, 2010)

Wednesday, November 10, 2010

Ohio: Nicholas Reynolds, 18, pleads guilty to stealing a baby alpaca and then beating it to death with his friends

OHIO -- A man has pleaded guilty to his role in the beating death of an alpaca last year.

Nicholas Reynolds (aka Nick Reynolds), 18, admitted to several charges Wednesday including animal cruelty, breaking and entering, tampering with evidence, vandalism and grand theft.


He will be sentenced in October. He could face more than 10 years in prison for the alpaca beating and failure to comply with a police officer in an unrelated case.


Investigators said Reynolds, another teen, and a 23-year-old woman stole the 3-month-old baby alpaca named Masterpiece from a Madison Township farm, took turns beating the baby to death and then dumped its tiny body at an abandoned barn in Montgomery County.


Reynolds' attorney said his client wasn't the one who initially beat the animal. Attorney Paris Ellis LIED AND told the judge that Reynolds hit it to put it out of its misery.

Masterpiece's owner, Jeff Pergram, was in court for the plea.

"I'm glad that he just manned up and admitted his guilt. That's a step forward for him also," said Pergram.

Pergram is pushing for legislation that would make animal cruelty a felony in Ohio. Pergram considers the beating the most disturbing charge in the crime but because it's a misdemeanor it carries a lighter sentence. He said that isn't right.

Pergram said he was so distraught by the loss of Masterpiece that he sold his other three alpacas. He originally owned the four for breeding and to sell the fleece.

 

The other two accused of the baby alpaca's torture death - Stacie Mullins and Marcus Miller - have trial dates set for later this year.

(WCPO - Nov 9, 2010)

Earlier:

Tuesday, November 9, 2010

NC toddler mauled by grandmother's 5 pit bulls

NORTH CAROLINA -- Authorities in North Carolina say a 2-year-old boy was mauled by his grandmother's five pit bulls and is in critical condition.

Graham County Sheriff's Capt. Joseph Jones said Monday that the boy was bitten on his neck, stomach and legs. Jones says the boy was attacked Saturday while playing in his yard, where several of the dogs were running free.

Police have quarantined five pit bulls at the Haywood County animal shelter, and they likely will be killed. Jones said the family kept the dogs as pets and was not breeding them.

The boy's grandmother told investigators she had been trying to give the dogs away.

Jones says no charges have been filed.

(UT San Diego - November 8, 2010)

Sunday, November 7, 2010

No punishment for dog that attacked 7-year-old-boy

SOUTH CAROLINA -- A 7-year-old boy was attacked by a dog outside his West Columbia home.

The boy's mother says his stitches are the result of an encounter with an unrestrained bull mastiff.

Brandy Hancock turned to the law for help, but found there isn't a lot of help available.


Austin Harris usually rides for fun, but on Tuesday morning, he rode to escape. "The dogs pulled him down, just tackled him and the other two dogs came after him, biting him, pulling on him like he was a chew toy," said Austin's mother, Brandy Hancock.

"It was scary, to me," said Harris. "I yelled, but I wasn't crying."

Thirteen dog bites and a bunch of stitches later, Austin's mother wanted action. An animal control officer did just that, following the law to the letter. "They are just letting the dog stay right next door, quarantined," said Hancock.

That's the law, but Brandi is flat-out mad. "Animal control came back over here and said the same thing, 'we cannot do anything,'" said Hancock.  "'There is not a law stating that we can take the dog from the owner just because of a dog attack.'"

The problem is, as police explain it, the dog had no officially reported prior attacks or even complaints against him. "We would encourage people with a problem, let us know about it and we'll certainly come out and see what we can do to make things better for them," said Maj. Jackie Brothers.

In other words, a dog with a complaint history will get the owner in trouble. Over a third of all homeowner policy liability claims are for dog bites, and the average settlement is nearly $25,000.

So while criminal charges may not come out of these cases, there's always the option for a civil lawsuit. The downside is that after a settlement, your insurance rates may go sky-high or you may be dropped altogether.

(WIS - Nov 6, 2010)

Friday, November 5, 2010

Owner identified in Saline dog attack; contests initial police report

MICHIGAN -- The owner of a dog accused of attacking and injuring another dog on Saline’s north side last month identified herself to police but disputes the other dog owner's version of events.

The woman came forward last week [only] after learning a subpoena was issued to her cell phone provider to verify her identity, police reports said.

Police requested the subpoena after multiple attempts to contact her about the Sept. 29 attack were unsuccessful.

A Saline woman reported her Golden Retriever was attacked by a dog that was on the same sidewalk in the 400 block of Berkshire Drive at about 4:45 p.m. She said the dog was on a leash, but pulled the 12-year-old girl holding the leash toward them.

The Golden Retriever suffered a serious leg injury that required sutures, and incurred a $433 veterinarian bill, reports said. The injured dog’s owner obtained a cell phone number for the girl, but told police a woman who described herself as her mother hung up on her when she called.

That woman told police her daughter said the Golden Retriever came after her dog while the girl was occupied trying to pick up her dog’s waste.

Officers cited the woman for having an unlicensed dog, but she came to Saline City Hall within the hour to obtain a license and show officers the animal’s vaccination records, reports said.

The woman told officers she planned to contact her attorney about the incident. The report will be forwarded to the city attorney’s office for review.

(AnnArbor.com - Nov 4, 2010)