Over the course of three separate incidents in the past decade — including one in Saskatchewan — 57-year-old April Irving has had more than 300 dogs taken away from her, many of them starving, matted and distressed.
RCMP say there are warrants for Irving's arrest in Alberta and Saskatchewan. She hasn't shown up in court since June 2016.
"It's really disheartening to know that she's not facing the justice system," said Deanna Thompson, executive director with the Alberta Animal Rescue Crew Society (AARCS), which dealt with Irving's most recent case.
"I'm really worried that she is somewhere, again, hidden far away from the public eye, doing the same thing right now."
Milk River dogs
When more than 200 dogs were seized from Irving's property in Milk River, Alta., two years ago, rescuers had never seen anything like it.
"I've never seen animals so emaciated in my entire life," Thompson said.
"They were covered in filth. The majority of them had to be shaved right down because they hadn't had grooming ever, probably."
Thompson said the dogs were full of internal parasites, many of which rescuers had never encountered before. The dogs were suffering with gastrointestinal issues stemming from prolonged starvation, which plague some of the animals to this day.
Prior conviction in Saskatchewan
Irving had dozens of dogs on her property in Milk River despite a 10-year ban imposed in Saskatchewan that forbid her from owning more than two dogs a time.
That prohibition was the result of a conviction under Saskatchewan's Animal Protection Act, after more than 80 dogs were taken from Irving's property near Foam Lake in 2010, many of them also dirty, matted and skinny.
That followed a case from 2007 when dogs were seized from Irving in Fort McMurray, Alta. Charges in that case were dropped.
"It's aggravating, because we do all of this work as SPCAs and humane societies to do the enforcement work, and then to have people just walk away from their charges repeatedly — it's hard to deal with," said Kaley Pugh from Animal Protection Services of Saskatchewan.
Pugh was not surprised to hear that Irving had accumulated more dogs in Alberta as she said Irving has never acknowledged any deficiencies in her care of the dogs.
"She always maintained that she loved her dogs and that she treated them like family," said Pugh, who sat through Irving's trial in Saskatchewan.
"Having that many dogs, it doesn't matter how much you love them or how much work you say you're doing. So I really wasn't surprised that she was over her head again."
In June 2016, Alberta courts referred Irving for psychiatric testing to assess her fitness to stand trial. Then she disappeared.
"I don't know how anyone can truly watch that many animals suffering," Thompson said.
"It was obvious the amount of suffering that they were going through and it's just awful to think that someone doesn't believe that what they were doing was wrong."
Two years later, all of the rescued Milk River dogs have been adopted through a massive undertaking by a number of rescue organizations.
"It was amazing to watch the animal welfare community in Alberta come together to care for these animals, and to give them everything that they needed in order to survive and thrive," Thompson said.
A reunion was held in October 2016, organized by 17-year-old Josiah Albers of Red Deer, Alta., who is making a documentary on the dogs' journey.
"They were some of the most well-behaved dogs that I'd seen," said Albers. "They were just super happy and running around and it was awesome to see."
But for some of the dogs, it has been a long road to recovery.
Gracie, an Irish wolfhound-husky cross, was one year old and just nine kilograms when she was taken from the Milk River property.
She now weighs almost 30 kilograms and has regrown the matted coat that needed to be shaved.
But on the inside, Gracie still has issues.
"She doesn't trust people, still, a year and a half later," said Katharine Boguski, who adopted Gracie. "She's been to the vet numerous times for issues, mostly digestive issues.
"She has separation anxiety, so when I leave the house, she cries."
Boguski said although Gracie is warming up to her husband, she is the only one who can walk the dog and let her off-leash at the dog park.
Boguski is furious that the woman allegedly responsible for Gracie's neglect has simply not shown up for her court dates.
"I am so angry," she said. "To think that other dogs could go through this again? Why is this lady allowed to do this? How can she not be stopped?"
"These animals need justice," said Thompson. "And not just for these animals but any other animal that may come into her care."
RCMP say Irving may be in Alberta, Saskatchewan or British Columbia.
(CBC - Jan 11, 2017)