"I had to shoot the other dogs, unfortunately, to get them to stop the attack," Mike Fay told WISN 12 NEWS on Monday in describing the Saturday afternoon attack near South 59th and West Burnham streets.
Fay said he knew the dogs lived near him but said he never had any problems with them.
On Saturday, however, the larger animals that police described as pit bulls were running loose and set their sights on Pepper.
Fay, a concealed carry permit holder, said he tried to break up the attack, but ran back to his house to get his gun.
"It was a last resort, not something I'd typically just jump out and do," he said. "I wish things had happened differently. ... I was afraid that they were going to kill my dog eventually."
It was in this alley that the two Pit Bulls attacked
Responding officers later gave Fay a ride to a nearby veterinary hospital, where Pepper was already being examined and stitched up in nearly a dozen places.
She was back home Monday, resting on medication with her head in a cone to prevent her from giving attention to her wounds.
PIT BULL OWNER DOESN'T WANT YOU TO KNOW HIS IDENTITY
Fay's neighbor, who asked to not be publicly identified, said "it was a very unfortunate incident" and that he had no hard feelings against Fay.
Fay said the two men have spoken and said there doesn't seem to be "bad blood" between them.
Really? He's not going to be criminally charged at all... so he's free to go buy two more Pit bulls this afternoon. Greaaaaaaaat.
(WISN - March 5, 2018)