Angelo Sullo appeared in Cleveland Municipal Court Tuesday with his attorney. He has pleaded not guilty to a charge of petty theft. He says due to this case his family has received death threats.
Sullo is accused of giving Army Private Katelyn Gallagher’s dog away, while she was attending military training out-of-state. Gallagher said Sullo told her he would watch Buck while she was gone.
Sullo insists the case is a misunderstanding.
“Honestly, he was looking out for the best interests of this dog,” said Sullo’s attorney, Tony Bondra. “He was facing eviction if he kept the dog so he found a good home.”
The family who has Buck now says they believe she gave away her rights to the dog. They say they adore Buck and plan to keep him.
“This dog belongs to Katelyn,” said Gallagher’s attorney, Paul Cristallo. “The family should do the right thing and give her the dog back.”
Gallagher is considering filing a civil suit.
Sullo is due back in court in February.
- Ohio: Army Private says her dog was sold by her "friend" Angelo Sullo while she was on training assignment
- Ohio: Facing theft charge, Angelo Sullo refuses to tell judge what he did with Army private's dog
- Ohio: Despite being told she is in possession of stolen property and that Angelo Sullo has been charged with theft, Christina Grapo refuses to return Bloodhound that belongs to army private